Post from Will Walker's Blog:
The Green Bandwagon
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.
Is anyone else as freaked out as I am by all these corporate "green" commercials? It's an understatement to say that I am skeptical not only of corporate motives (which, of course, are driven entirely by profit) but, more importantly, of their ability to deliver on their promises without massive unanticipated costs. Every day, I get more frightened that this movement of ours is being corrupted by corporate agents who only see an opportunity to make a quick buck rather than an opportunity to rescue the planet from sure environmental devastation.

We have already seen some of this corruption in upstate New York with the wind farms in the northern part of the state. Wind companies are apparently colluding with local officials to gobble up land, and in the process they are dividing communities and exploiting vulnerable populations.

It's time for us to take some responsibility for the forces we have played a role in unleashing. If we don't our whole movement may be tainted and the opportunity for meaningful change lost.

Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

  
"Green" Gas guzzlers
By Unknown user, Sep 11, 2008 at 3:43:31 PM ET (Updated: Sep 11, 2008 at 3:43:31 PM ET )
Will,

Funny, I have a friend here in Michigan named Will and he owns a recycling company.

Anyway, I hear you. I can't believe the automakers are coming out with commercials that make it look like their cars are soooo fuel efficient. Like the Saturn Vue, touting itself as a gas "sipper" at 26 miles per gallon. Heck, my old clunker low tech '94 Toyota 4-Runner gets almost that if I practice hyper miling. And I'm running into the ground until the hybrid plug-in biofuel clean diesels hit the showrooms.

This is supposed to be a revelation, a benefit? You shouldn't even be in the conversation if you're under 35 miles a gallon. If I were an automaker, I would be embarrassed to make such a bogus claim. We should all be getting 40 mpg by 2010. That's what the market wants. With clean emissions to boot!

We've got some budding wind farms out here in Michigan, mostly leased by farmers. We'll have to hold on and see if they start barking. Any time big business energy gets involved, that corruption like in New York State can't be far behind.

Speaking of upstate New York, Praxair is trying to lure one of your towns (can't remember which) and Holland, MI into a multimillion dollar "clean" coal carbon sequestration power plant. That means they'll pipe the burned carbon gases into the ground. And dig this, this new plant will INCREASE our energy bills by 60%. Are they crazy?

Let's see... they want to kick the environmentalists in the teeth, sell the population on "new, clean" technology (nothing about coal is clean), and pick our pockets while were down. Naw, there's nothing wrong with this picture is there? I think I'll move to Brazil where they are light years ahead of us.

Meaningful change? You gotta wait for the revolution, pal.
  
coal is not dirty
By Unknown user, Sep 16, 2008 at 5:37:02 PM ET (Updated: Sep 16, 2008 at 5:37:02 PM ET )
Have you been to rural Brazil? Brown outs are the norm. You may think coal is dirty, but educate yourself about the current technology of modern coal plants and you might be suprised. One half of all power plants in the US are coal for a reason......................it is still the cheapest and most reliable system out there..........and remember that the current power system was structered and built under government regulation because it was essentially a monopoly. I have nothing against renewable energy, in fact I drive a Prius, but the sun doesn't shine @ night, and the wind doesn't blow all the time..........unless you want your power bill to quadruple or more overnight (10 years) it ain't gonna happin my friend!
Re: coal is not dirty
By Unknown user, Sep 17, 2008 at 12:14:37 AM ET (Updated: Sep 17, 2008 at 12:14:37 AM ET )
I'm not sure about the opening poster, I understand where You're coming from, and like the "wait for the revolution" comment, It disgusts me that so many here are WHINING about GM (& others) playing on "Green".
1-Toyota put out the RAV4E (for ELECTRIC) in 2003, range, 150 mi. @ 78mph w/a full load (read 4 200+lb persons & 125lbs of "luggage". Poor Toyota was mfg'ing the batteries under lease of patent m. GM, who sold to Texaco, who sold to Citgo(as in Hugo Chavez) & the plug got pulled. Take a min., do a search on Rav4E...& see I speak the truth. The technology has BEEN OUT THERE.
2-Opening Poster(Will), stop Whining! Not on a soapbox, just stating facts....
A-We have a '97 Ford 7.3 Powerstroke Extended Cab Diesel which gets 22mpg. It's 2WD & I use it for work. Haven't bought diesel in 2 + years, as I make my own biodiesel, and have a 120 gal. tank in the bed for WVO which it's also set up to run off of directly...combination of the 2 has a cost of about 55 cents a gallon & ZERO harmful emissions.
B-We got a mortgage, we bought the Solar Panels, and we produce 10kw of electricity when the sun shines.
C-I went to Pacwind.org and bought a VAWT (Vertical wind turbine->imagine squirril cage fan, mounted on an ALTERNATOR, mounted on a pole...another 9kw produced any time the wind blows > 3mph & < 100mph.
D-Converted a military skid mounted 15kw 60hz generator to also run on bioDiesel AND WVO...any time I have a few dozen gallons left over, I fire it up, and all of this is while helping out local restaurant owners who were having to PAY to get rid of their used cooking oil.
YES, all of this DID cost a lot of money...guess what, folks, instead of TALKING about what everybody ELSE SHOULD Do, we chose to actually DO IT Ourselves, and compliments of Net Metering, we get a hefty check back from our utility company every month, and needless to say, aside From that CHECK, I've been tempted for a long time to tell them to "Go Pound Sand". Our bill has been zero for a while now, our income mid range 4 figures per month for an equally long while. Imagine this....the Sierra Club Members in Gainesville produce over 100kw added back to GRU (Gainesville Regional Utilities) every month. They like me Practice before they preach.
You want to change the world?
You Want to Make Sure the "Cause" doesn't get "hijacked"?
Well then start IN YOUR BACKYARD!
Stop worrying and start DOING!
Talk is cheap, keystrokes cheaper, I typed this & sent it to all of it's readers via Batteries in my garage, paired to 9kw in inverters, getting charged by silicon chip by day & wind as this is typed. & for me at least it wasn't cheap words, it was FREE ELECTRICITY!
Shut Up & Start Shopping!
When the naysayers give You Grief, whip out Your wallet (as I do) & Show 'em Your Pride(solar panels) & Joy (VAWT) & march 'em over to Your vehicle...wife & I are converting 2 cars to h2o Hybrids next (yes, that means they run on WATER!).
Leadership by example isn't the "best" way, it's the ONLY way....to actually LEAD.
(Ask me how many solar panels Al Gore has?)
Clean Coal?
NUKES? WHY? (for either option)
I'd take Coal over NUKES and neither by preference...You know why MY way isn't getting press & Exposure? Because mine doesn't NEED an Electric "Company". We could easily power our NEIGHBORHOOD, so when they (Progress Energy) say NUKES are "clean" I want to bring them some Radium in a DeCon Suit at the public hearing & ask them what the half life is?
I'm allowed to be sarcastic, I walk the walk already, remember?
It feels good, join in, start shopping start producing.
  
Dumbing down the message.
By Unknown user, Sep 19, 2008 at 2:23:19 PM ET (Updated: Sep 19, 2008 at 2:23:19 PM ET )
Yes it has worried me form the beginning that being green for the sake of selling us more crap would dilute the importance of what I have been trying to tell people for most of my life. It’s now stylish to be “Green”. Well stuff goes in and out of style and when it’s out its put aside as passé. This isn’t good. I don’t know how many people I’ve come across lately who just tune me out when I start to talk about global warming. They have that oh that’s old news look on their face. Geeze, there is so much evidence to prove the danger we are facing! How big of a hurricane do we need? The commercial telling everyone that the problems that are hurtling at us are all coming form the same source is so very important. We need people to hear this message. I guess we should take a page form the republican play book, Make it simple and just keep repeating it over and over.
  
...the bandwagon...right!
By MjrSail100, Oct 29, 2008 at 11:12:33 PM ET (Updated: Oct 29, 2008 at 11:12:33 PM ET )
the corporate bandwagers have made me sceptical as well. are they really changing for the better...one can only know. we need to be doing our due dilegence by asking the tough questions and fighting for what we believe in.

i'm changing careers right now and renewables..wind in particular...is a major area i'm targeting. i've been networking with as many people as possible in and around this industry.
I've learned that there are two types of wind farm developers...the legitimate ones that negotiate the land deals, build, operate and maintain the turbines/farms and the corrupt ones, or "land pirates/flippers," like you've experienced in NY, that are simply in for the $ tied to the land deals...with no regard for the local population and long term sustainibility of the projects, etc.

I'm told that there is only about 7-8 legitimate wind farm developers (utility scale), out of about 25 operating in the US. Not sure if this is completely accurate, but it wouldn't surprise me, unfortunately. The only way to defuse these greed driven entities is to stick with those that are committed to the industries "best practices" and the long-term viability of the projects including all thier stakeholders.
  
we get knocked down, but get back up
By together one can have massive footprints, Jan 9, 2009 at 2:06:28 PM ET (Updated: Jan 9, 2009 at 2:06:28 PM ET )
green jobs. i don't really like this trendy "green" word. if you'll notice, the media uses violence, sex, and fear to gain attention. "green" seems so careless and optional. we "green" thinkers need to attack this problem with the same crude tactics. instead of "green" why not call them "pro-life" jobs and then point out how we are all going to fall victim to the same inevitable narcissistic fate if we don't comply. war, abortion, racism can all be pooled into this collective medium representing mankind's struggle and survival. the problem is we're not pointing at a clock of hours left, we're not showing the millions of deaths from environmental change, warmongering, and history which will all be forgotten if we're so willing to become the past. you want more "green" jobs? tell people they directly assure the death of no less than five living entities per person (pictures like abortion protests) each day they choose to continue to live in this consumer market and since our entertainment is willing to expose the population to disgusting imagery maybe we can utilize that to our advantage. i like that," you want entertainment, we'll give you the truth". i'm sickened by the destruction and gluttony, and frankly i'm tired of being pooled with so many of these sheep the world views as monsters. i live in america and i struggle in america, i see gross inhumane america, it exists, but we need to become an entity the world can see as trying, caring, compassionate, and very concerned for everyone's well being. we, the people, control the market. if you want american jobs, you only buy american products. if you want "green" jobs, point out the resolution to the people. we collectively hear all about the problems, but individually hear nothing about how donating one dollar each can be enough to create an entire industry with our own dollars (over 2 million from this site alone, count me in). this is an issue the government hasn't figured out how to control yet, so they keep to their well-oiled machine. we need to point out that our government is full of treason and why are they not being tried? be blunt, bold, confident, steadfast, harsh, and cruel to get our point across. it was once what we were founded upon,......leadership, but it has never been identified with congressional seats but instead with individuals. deny the name "consumer" and appoint the name "lover". ghandi showed its capabilities, now show the world its resonance. we have to change or we will die, much sooner. your children will die. everything you are working your life away for will fade and only the ghosts of actions not taken will haunt us all. for the children, by the people, against the setting of the sun, unify as mankind, from one we must now stand as one. we are made up of millions of organisms for the sole purpose of dictating reason and assuring common wealth, i will fight only for this and never allow myself to be clouded by outside opposition. be sure of and for one's self only to sever the false walls between us all. in the eyes of a nameless god we struggle. stop and come together, right now, with me.